You're telling me writing something on a piece of paper in a liberal system predicated on being capitalist can't actually get rid of liberals?
Organize, comrades.
this post was submitted on 22 Sep 2024
318 points (97.3% liked)
World News
32510 readers
780 users here now
News from around the world!
Rules:
-
Please only post links to actual news sources, no tabloid sites, etc
-
No NSFW content
-
No hate speech, bigotry, propaganda, etc
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
If voting changed anything they wouldn’t let us do it.
France could use a new Republic. what're they on, six now?
id recommend a commune
But this time seize the fucking bank
- The united left wants a sixth with major change from that slow inefficient fifth.
It took me a while to understand what you meant because we don't write anything on our ballots. There are piles of small cards with one candidate (or list) on each, we (are supposed to) pick one of each and put one in the envelope.
But yeah, I agree with your take.
Don't mind me. I'm jist digging through my post history to give a big fat "I told you so" to all the liberals on Lemmy.
I'm hoping the Communists in France have been reading their Lenin. I can't think of a better gift Macron could have given the communists. "Left-Wing" Communism, an Infantile Disorder
Chapter 9: “Left-Wing” Communism in Great Britian
~~Lloyd George~~ Macron entered into a polemic... with those Liberals who want, not a coalition with the Conservatives, but closer relations with the ~~Labour Party~~ New Popular Front (NPF)... ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron argued that a coalition—and a close coalition at that—between the Liberals and the Conservatives was essential, otherwise there might be a victory for the ~~Labour Party~~ NPF which ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron prefers to call “Socialist” ... "In Germany it was called socialism, and in Russia it is called Bolshevism," he went on to say. To Liberals this is unacceptable on principle, ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron explained, because they stand in principle for private property. “Civilisation is in jeopardy,” the speaker declared, and consequently Liberals and Conservatives must unite. . . .
... Thus the liberal bourgeoisie are abandoning the historical system of “two parties” (of exploiters), which has been hallowed by centuries of experience and has been extremely advantageous to the exploiters, and consider it necessary for these two parties to join forces against the ~~Labour Party~~ NPF.
...
At present, ~~British~~ French Communists very often find it hard even to approach the masses, and even to get a hearing from them. If I come out as a Communist and call upon them to vote for ~~Henderson~~ Castets and Mélenchon and against ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron and Le Pen they will certainly give me a hearing. And I shall be able to explain in a popular manner, not only why the Soviets are better than a parliament and why the dictatorship of the proletariat is better than the dictatorship of ~~Churchill~~ Barnier and Le Pen (disguised with the signboard of bourgeois “democracy”), but also that, with my vote, I want to support ~~Henderson~~ Castets and the NPF in the same way as the rope supports a hanged man—that the impending establishment of a government of the ~~Hendersons~~ Castets will prove that I am right, will bring the masses over to my side, and will hasten the political death of the ~~Hendersons~~ Castetses and the ~~Snowdens~~ Mélenchons just as was the case with their kindred spirits in Russia and Germany.
...
This has stripped more and more active and engaged and hopeful people of their illusions about bourgeois democracy than even bernie-clinton 2016 nonsense. Which even that created a lot of communists; and that was relatively milquetoast compared to this huge national mobilization and upswell and coalition movement which was big enough to make international headlines no less. If the French communists have been reading their Lenin and agitating on this stuff even before it happened (as you said, very predictable) then the communist movement has gained 10x more than any eurosocialist thinks "the left" lost.
Bold to think they won't move the goal posts again
load more comments
(1 replies)
Bit weird that the left have won the elections, yet the president gets to decide how the government is formed...
France has a weird hybrid Presidential/Parliamentary system that no other country has and is really confusing.
Most other countries either have a diminished President whose only real duty is making sure there is a Prime Minister that has a mandate to lead or an empowered President that has a democratic mandate and has more leeway to run the government's administration.
That is confusing, indeed.
It's not that rare in Europe actually, for example Poland have very similar government forming procedure, and guess what, after most recent elections Polish president Duda tried to do identical maneuver, but unlike in France the elections weren't this close so he didn't really tried to do de-facto coup like Macron, just mostly maneuvered to exhaust all his time-delaying procedures to give his party colleagues from ending term time to jump the ship safely, destroy the compromising documents (literally, the central security service ABW bought lots of large paper shredders right after elections)
load more comments
(2 replies)
Thank you France for finally putting to bed the myth that western democracy works and the only problem is that people just have to vote harder.
I've certainly not seen someone wipe his ass with the people's vote quicker than this guy.
If anything it shows that authoritarians will choose what keeps them in power rather than what's best for the people. The left didn't get the majority, it was roughly a 3 way split between the left, center-right and far-right. The government would've been with the left and center-right or center-right and far-right. The former would've been better because it would've represented a bigger portion of the voters but the latter was also viable from the perspective of democracy.
However the choice was largely up to Macron (and his party) and he's definitely more autocratic than democratic. His decision is what ultimately threw the left under the bus.
Tldr: Democracy is fine, authoritarianism is the issue.
What is shows is that western implementation of the concept of democracy is such that it does not represent the interests of the working majority. Western democracies are class dictatorships where the capital owning class makes the decisions and dictates to the workers. This is precisely what we're seeing happening in France right now.
Meanwhile, authoritarianism is a largely meaningless term. Every government holds authority by virtue of having a monopoly on legalized violence. What actually matters is whom the government is accountable to. When the working majority has no tangible leverage then their voice can be easily ignored. That's why Macron is able to do what he is doing. The issue is with the way the system is implemented.
TLDR: democracy is fine, western implementation of the concept is not
load more comments
(25 replies)
France's public-sector deficit is projected to reach around 5.6% of GDP this year and go over 6% in 2025. The EU has a 3% limit on deficits.
oh no, not even Germany follows that deficit limit, its literally a number they pulled out of their asses to fuck up welfare systems. fucking BBC
Fuck CDU/AfD. Germany is already taking the wrong side of history.
Wouldn’t be the first time, won’t be the last time
the illegal and undemocratic annexation of the gdr really was a tragedy.
Germany is already taking the wrong side of history.
Always has been
Also to force privatisations on the member states who don't have the clout to just ignore the rules
load more comments
(1 replies)
Far-left leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon
Mélenchon. Far-left. Come on!
At best left, not remotely far left.
Exactly
what was the quote about how elections cannot be allowed to alter economic policy? 
Remember a bunch of years ago when the news were all about cheering this guy for having defeat his fascist opponent?
Cut a Liberal and a Fascist bleeds
Cut an anticommunist and an anticommunist bleeds?
Macron really going out of his way to fuck over the French people, eh? Calls snap elections right after the far right wins big in eu elections, then refuses to follow the will of the people when said election backfires.
Part of my thinks the left will be better off in opposition, though.
During 2022 the French left was saying "A vote for Macron in 2022 is a vote for Le Pen in 2027".
They appear to be right on schedule.
Calls snap elections right after the far right wins big in eu elections
That's the only reason they did that lmao. They were hoping the far-right would win, and ignored the results because they didn't.
Macron took his mask off and never put it back on.
So…does France go apeshit, or are they all revolutioned out?
To be fair we're pretty tired and hopeless, most people are apathetic now because nothing seems to be working.
Strikes and demonstrations are vilified by the media, the left is not united enough to hit as hard as they should, the president is a child throwing tantrums to have it the way he wants, the media is owned by very few people so they control the narrative, etc.
It honestly feels hopeless, most people want change, but to a lot of people the demonising of the left has worked and the far right seems to be a reasonable option now.
It's gonna get a lot worse before it gets better unfortunately...
because nothing seems to be working.
This is an inspiring sign for communists. No reason for pessimism. A large mobilization of masses of engaged politically active workers in a state where the masses still largely believe in parliamentarism; who formed sprawling coalitions into a large left national upswelling that also made international headlines, now have themselves and onlookers been shown, better than any propaganda alone ever could, why bourgeois liberal democracy is an impediment to progress rather than a channel for it; and that the Liberals will side with the fascists to keep the left from getting an inch. This has made more communists than you probably realize. Especially if your communists have been reading their Lenin and agitating on this point, which probably a lot of workers didn't even need much agitation to expect this because of the state of things and how just... unbearably awful Macron is in every way
VI Lenin: LWC Chapter 9: “Left-Wing” Communism in Great Britian
~~Lloyd George~~ Macron entered into a polemic... with those Liberals who want, not a coalition with the Conservatives, but closer relations with the ~~Labour Party~~ New Popular Front (NPF)... ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron argued that a coalition—and a close coalition at that—between the Liberals and the Conservatives was essential, otherwise there might be a victory for the ~~Labour Party~~ NPF which ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron prefers to call “Socialist” ... "In Germany it was called socialism, and in Russia it is called Bolshevism," he went on to say. To Liberals this is unacceptable on principle, ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron explained, because they stand in principle for private property. “Civilisation is in jeopardy,” the speaker declared, and consequently Liberals and Conservatives must unite. . . .
... Thus the liberal bourgeoisie are abandoning the historical system of “two parties” (of exploiters), which has been hallowed by centuries of experience and has been extremely advantageous to the exploiters, and consider it necessary for these two parties to join forces against the ~~Labour Party~~ NPF.
...
At present, ~~British~~ French Communists very often find it hard even to approach the masses, and even to get a hearing from them. If I come out as a Communist and call upon them to vote for ~~Henderson~~ Castets and Mélenchon and against ~~Lloyd George~~ Macron and Le Pen they will certainly give me a hearing. And I shall be able to explain in a popular manner, not only why the Soviets are better than a parliament and why the dictatorship of the proletariat is better than the dictatorship of ~~Churchill~~ Barnier and Le Pen (disguised with the signboard of bourgeois “democracy”), but also that, with my vote, I want to support ~~Henderson~~ Castets and the NPF in the same way as the rope supports a hanged man—that the impending establishment of a government of the ~~Hendersons~~ Castets will prove that I am right, will bring the masses over to my side, and will hasten the political death of the ~~Hendersons~~ Castetses and the ~~Snowdens~~ Mélenchons just as was the case with their kindred spirits in Russia and Germany.
...
It is a good day friend. Communism will win, and these liberal politicians are helping it do so. Don't let the systems and their media and propaganda make you believe otherwise in their lies. They're trying to convince you of your own defeat because of the implications if you don't believe you have been, and instead realize they're selling you the rope they will be hanged with; and you push harder in smarter ways that they can't keep up with, using connections built in these mass movements and coalitions which invariably have radical new elements that just need drawn together.
You're ahead of them in this. They've, in a very real dialectical way, undermined liberal democracy and created more enemies to the capitalist systems and institutions than they made allies, by their own blunders in being incapable of conceding anything to intelligently reify socialists back into feckless parliamentary legitimization of bourgeois democracy, and their failures to navigate contradictions in ways that aren't so short-sighted to look absolutely villainous to huge swathes of the population (and internationally, because this was a large enough movement to make headlines around the world; with a knock-on effect for the international proles who see parallels). Macron's so scared of radical politics he's making them everywhere he steps.
load more comments
(2 replies)
I’m not saying what they’ll do but the concept of the French being “revolutioned out” borders on comical. It may be beheadings or merely stacking trash in the street, but they aren’t known for staying quiet.
I think they will go increasingly Vichy just with Berlin replaced with Washington, through Berlin.
Plenty of people are protesting for one cause or another, see the troubles at the olympics. You don't hear much about it on mass media anymore because governments figured out that it's better to keep silent about it or protests spread.
Scratch a liberal
The assemblée nationale can block and cause the prime minister to resign can't they? Can the left wing alliance not join forces again to veto the pm appointment? I guess the problem is that they managed to do it to repel the le pen's party but not all left leaning parties are similarly united against Barnier's government.
They could but they won't have enough votes to go through with it unfortunately. The assembly is roughly 33% of the three big groups, the united left, Macron's party and the far right. With the united left having slightly more seats than the other two.
view more: next ›