this post was submitted on 22 Jul 2023
1517 points (77.8% liked)
Memes
45760 readers
1282 users here now
Rules:
- Be civil and nice.
- Try not to excessively repost, as a rule of thumb, wait at least 2 months to do it if you have to.
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
Incredible how you call me butthurt but don't substantiate any of your claims whatsoever, just slinging insults as an argument. My what mechanism would communism always lead to tyranny? What mechanism makes "greedy selfish and materialistic" people destroy socialism from within? Do you think that Marx's ideology, a strictly and explicitly materialist one itself, wouldn't consider people are materialistic?
Police aren't the only form of law enforcement that could ever exist. if you're too "lazy" to think outside the box, whatever, but don't blame communists for doing it.
Yes I'm aware you would still work under communism, but you are once again using the conditions of capitalist production and just placing them in the communist mode of production assuming they wouldn't be fundamentally altered by the substantively different economic conditions. You never lived under communism, at best you lived under socialism, and most of your peers statistically prefer it to capitalism.
Communism is not an empathy-driven system, so your whole line about not caring about me is pretty pointless. What property do you even have to share? Are you going to resort to the "toothbrush" argument?
Scientific socialism was a term coined by Engels to describe marxism, is this your first time hearing it? You list out a bunch of "bogus" but can't seem to substantiate those claims. Maybe if you could you wouldn't have to "guess" that they're bogus?
LMAO, patently false. Capitalism is its own ideology too with its own theory and proponents and ideals.
Once again you prove your lack of understanding of Marxism by not understanding the distinction between communism and socialism.
You have still failed to explain how exactly people not being perfect undermines socialism. It seems like you think you can hide your lack of substance behind snarky self-righteousness but you're not making any actual criticism besides venting your obvious animosity towards socialists
tldr "I don't care about your opinion because my opinion is right and I don't have to back it up"
It's insane how dismissive you manage to be while also not substantiating any of your claims in any meaningful way aside from vaguely gesturing at communism itself or saying that it's not worth talking about
you keep saying "communists don't know this or that about communism" and that you're trying to discover what "communism might look like" when I told you in my first comment that trying to predict the minutia of communism is utopian
LMAO what???
I'm honestly still not sure what you mean by science didn't exist at the time or what context you might be referring to
You aren't supposed to build communism, we are supposed to build socialism, only when generations are reared in the social conditions of the socialist mode of production, and the international conditions allow, and the productive capacity allows, can the transition from socialism to communism take place.
Basically we are too far off from communism to build it directly and to predict the fine details of what it may look like, we need to build socialism first