Red Dead Redemption (1): "My Name Is John Marston"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PD24MkbHQrc
Still gives me goosebumps how amazing this looks for 2010, like an actual Sergio Leone western film turned into a game. And then they somehow exceeded expectations with it.
Also a shoutout to Aladdin on Sega Genesis. Both games had amazing production value for their time.