Boohoo. Blind test of 5 photos with a 3-2 margin which could go in a completely different way if repeated with a different set of audience or even the same set of audience at a different time. These comparison are pointless.
In reality both are two great devices and if someone sees either of the pics independently, they'll barely have anything to complain about. We'll compare if were forced to compare.
Also, who the hell calls it "iDevice" of all things.
Got good promotions from my carrier and then been getting free upgrades (except tax) every year so why not.