I think it may be better to collect ideas first and then create a new post with all the entries as comments. Currently whatever gets commented first has the advantage of time to collect the votes. Just a thought tho.
this post was submitted on 20 Jan 2025
108 points (97.4% liked)
196
1446 readers
3820 users here now
This community only has one rule.
Rule: You must post before you leave.
founded 2 days ago
MODERATORS
Probably let this thread run for a few days, and then create a poll thread with all the suggestions
Why not use the one from Reddit, it has 196 Mascot in it
Here's a 512² icon:
If anyone wants the SVG file to edit it further, here's a link.
The shark was stolen from a Reddit post and then manually redrawn by me.
This is my vote. This one's quality.
Well done!
That's beautiful! Chef's kiss mwah right there!
Surfacing this to the top for visibility, the old banner but as a Niko Oneshot textbox:
Niko ftw!!
no rule in title = eat 100 gummy sharks as punishment
196 you mean.
no rule in title = molten gold poured down ones throat
thatescalatedquickly.gif
@Cornflake@pawb.social also submitted an alternate icon version.
I'm voting for this one (and the one with blue bg too)
On the default lemmy ui at least, it looks like icons tend to be either ~20x20 when they're the small circle in the actual post, and 120x120 when they're in the community view as the 2 main sizes, and 24x24 also shows up in the community list section. Figured I'd mention some sizes in case it helps anyone designing an icon!
Folks might want to see how these look at those dimensions:
20x20
120x120
Good idea yeah! The 20x20 one will look a little more crunchy than the actual icon would end up, since the actual image file is still higher quality than 20x20 in terms of pixel density, its just the displayed height/width that gets smaller.
The 20x20 one will probably be closer to the same quality as the 120x120 one you posted (probably a bit more blurry), and the 120x120 size will be closer to the full quality one.
Thanks for bringing this up! I was skeptical anything remotely complex would look good in the 20x20 when I first saw the original response
Rule old rule
Icon:
Banner:
Bad memories rule.
Like someone else said, bad memories for that though i would rock with the same banner text in a different design
but also, taking one last opportunity: wtf is the icon?
i recently realized half of it at least is Armenian Corey
something else is overlaid and i can’t tell what…
How about a Niko Oneshot textbox:
yus ! 😍😍 please post as a top level comment if you haven’t so it can be considered
Done.
It was the reddit icon at the time of migration two years ago. It's the default subreddit icon overlayed with armenian corey overlayed with a funny looking bird.
ah! i see the subreddit icon but i can’t make out the bird
the bird is a little difficult to see because I'm pretty sure they were slowly adding more opacity to Armenian Cory
I like the old banner, just needs something behind it