this post was submitted on 20 Oct 2024
113 points (97.5% liked)
Explain Like I'm Five
14289 readers
1 users here now
Simplifying Complexity, One Answer at a Time!
Rules
- Be respectful and inclusive.
- No harassment, hate speech, or trolling.
- Engage in constructive discussions.
- Share relevant content.
- Follow guidelines and moderators' instructions.
- Use appropriate language and tone.
- Report violations.
- Foster a continuous learning environment.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
The rich use a multiparty trick to stay rich:
Put their money in an offshore account that doesn't tax them based on wealth in the country. Typically the deal is the managers get some very small amounts, single digit percentages, to charge the customer for moving money in or out of the country. Then they never touch this money again unless it is an emergency.
The rich then use their bank account full of money as collateral for a loan that is much smaller, like a few million borrowed with a secured loan linked to the millions/billions in the account. The banks easily accept the terms because they can't lose - if the loan defaults the amount is pulled from the account. But the rich usually try to make their payments so that account money isn't touched.
The rich spend their loaned money and make payments from the dividends, annuities, funds, and/or interest on their principal amount. This way the bank gave the person money that they can spend and it's not income so they aren't taxed on it, unless there is a sales tax. It's basically free money.
As they spend this free money, the government for the country that they live in doesn't know how much money the rich person actually has so they are unable to create an accurate amount to tax them. This is partially why folks like Bezos and Buffet pay a few hundred thousand dollars on hundreds of billions in actual wealth. Stock valuations are an entirely other beast but functions roughly the same way as having wealth to borrow money against.
The rich stays rich and get free money because the banking system was made by them and they are educated by their accountants and financial advisors on how to pay the least amount of money they can to get the most out of each cent.
In addition, all the secured loans they take make them look on paper as though they are deeply in debt and that debt then is a tax write off. This further lowers their tax brackets so they pay even less. Add to this that in the US at least only income is taxed, all of the stocks, options, and other assets they hold are non-taxable since they aren’t cash; technically their value can (and does) change regularly and they can become worthless just as easily as they can gain value and so it was determined they aren’t income since nothing is realized until they are sold.
How much money makes this worthwhile? Asking for a friend.
This. Why is this system not exploitable by us? What do we need ti make this work for us? Also: if the system is known, why is nothing done about it?
The system is created by the people who use it.
It’s not that easy to do something about it. Generally you’re taxed in the country where you earn money, but corporations have options in where they count income and where they count losses, to most benefit them.
A regular person in the US can’t do this because their employer reports salary income to the IRS as US income. What income do you have that you can claim was earned in a low tax country? Have you done all the legal work and paid appropriate taxes in that country?
Sometimes you’ll read about repatriating money. How do you legally use that money you have in a low tax country without incurring taxes bringing it back to wherever you are?
I personally know someone who uses something he calls "Dutch reach-around" and while I'm hazy on the details, I know it starts with some complex setup of a charitable foundation in your home country, with real people and real money and a network of firms and other foundations in the Netherlands that are somehow interwoven. He told me "setup is cheap, only 5 million dollars up front, you can ask my tax attorney for the deets"....
That was a nice move, but no thank you, this is not the kind of money I have lying around.
Bonus how us firms do it, I imagine this costs also a lot of money up front...
Simple. It's purely by design.
I believe they also write off as much as they can as income losses to reduce their tax bill. Minimal or no income? No taxes.
A lot of the expenses are NOT substantiated but limp dick IRS won't do their fucking job. Same with SEC...
Useless regime whores
The IRS only has a limp dick because Repubs won't allow Congress to pay for their Viagra.
Amazing how party for the "working people" never deliveres anything for them as if it was designed that way by a regime
Interest income is definitely taxed.
Also the old fashioned olive oil scheme is still in use
I can't find anything about it except fake olive oil sale.
Do you have any sources?
I think this might be what they are talking about. Brilliant video, the story just builds and builds and builds. https://youtu.be/K4yCXIZ32lk
Oh cool, thanks!
EDIT Oh that's two hours, yeah sorry if that's lazy but I'm not going to watch a 2 hour video for a reference (and I'm too deaf to be able to follow this as a podcast). Thanks anyway!