Moving to: m/AskMbin!

49 readers

1 users here now

### We are moving! **Join us in our new journey as we take a new direction towards the future for this community at mbin, find our new community here and read this post to know more about why we are moving. Thank you and we hope to see you there!**

founded 1 year ago

What happens when an instance or magazine/community closes? (kbin.social)

submitted 1 year ago by shepherd@kbin.social to c/AskKbin@kbin.social

11 comments fedilink hide all child comments

So I've gone with kbin over lemmy for now, folks seem pretty friendly here.

Main question:
I understand that the point of the Fediverse is (relatively) easy access to decentralized communities. But what happens if the folks in charge of an instance decide they want to close it?

If ernest suddenly decides he wants to close kbin, is all the content just lost? Do we have ways to migrate the content/users/everything?

Even the reddit blackout was noticeably "someone else says you can't have this anymore" so I'm a little more sensitive to this than normal lol.

I realize we're in the early stages of the Fediverse, so it may just be a matter of patience while the smart people figure it out lol. But instance-death or long-term community-blackout seems like a risk across the whole fediverse!

Followup question:
If I post content, should I be basically spreading it across several instances to ensure my contributions aren't lost when someone else closes up shop?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] Otome-chan@kbin.social 5 points 1 year ago (2 children)

The content hosted on the site will be gone. with the mastodon stuff they already have a way to download your content and be able to reupload it on another instance (migrating). but that isn't a thing for lemmy/kbin just yet.

notably, beehaw just announced they're defederating from lemmy.world so go check that drama if you wanna see what happens.

If I post content, should I be basically spreading it across several instances to ensure my contributions aren't lost when someone else closes up shop?

Yeah if all your posts are on a single instance, then naturally when that instance closes that's going away lol. the nature of the fediverse is federation and decentralization so you should just post freely to various instances as you please.

[–] ChemicalRascal@lemmy.world 1 points 1 year ago

with the mastodon stuff they already have a way to download your content and be able to reupload it on another instance (migrating).

I don't think you can reupload content, at least not yet. I recently migrated off of home.social, and there wasn't any way to upload the resulting data export at my new Mastodon instance.

[–] shepherd@kbin.social 1 points 1 year ago (1 children)

Yeah, I'm unpacking the beehaw news! I think that's different though, I'm more concerned about a community's content becoming inaccessible (closed, deleted, locked, etc). Beehaw's content is still there, even Lemmy users can still access beehaw content by just visiting.

Yeah if all your posts are on a single instance, then naturally when that instance closes that's going away lol. the nature of the fediverse is federation and decentralization so you should just post freely to various instances as you please.

I guess that's just the "trade off" here? It's a little bit spammier than I usually prefer, but if it's for the sake of enduring content I guess I'll take the deal lol. Everyone post to every instance always!

[–] Otome-chan@kbin.social 1 points 1 year ago

It's not really that different from how reddit has /r/gaming and /r/games that serve pretty much the same purpose. except on the fediverse they're just named the same things but on different instances.

looking at the beehaw/lemmy stuff, there might be gaming@lemmy.world and gaming@beehaw.org and they can't access each other's content now because they defederated. If a lemmy.world user followed both, they'd now only see lemmy.world's community. whereas on kbin we're still federated with both, so we'd be able to see and interact with both.

Maybe a bit weird to get used to, but it's just the nature of federation. How you decide to participate in them is entirely up to you, but IMO it's probably just best to use the communities/groups/magazines you like.