Welcome to !reddit. This is a community for all news and discussions about Reddit.
The rules for posting and commenting, besides the rules defined here for lemmy.world, are as follows:
Rule 1- No brigading.
**You may not encourage brigading any communities or subreddits in any way. **
YSKs are about self-improvement on how to do things.
Rule 2- No illegal or NSFW or gore content.
**No illegal or NSFW or gore content. **
Rule 3- Do not seek mental, medical and professional help here.
Do not seek mental, medical and professional help here. Breaking this rule will not get you or your post removed, but it will put you at risk, and possibly in danger.
Rule 4- No self promotion or upvote-farming of any kind.
That's it.
Rule 5- No baiting or sealioning or promoting an agenda.
Posts and comments which, instead of being of an innocuous nature, are specifically intended (based on reports and in the opinion of our crack moderation team) to bait users into ideological wars on charged political topics will be removed and the authors warned - or banned - depending on severity.
Rule 6- Regarding META posts.
Provided it is about the community itself, you may post non-Reddit posts using the [META] tag on your post title.
Rule 7- You can't harass or disturb other members.
If you vocally harass or discriminate against any individual member, you will be removed.
Likewise, if you are a member, sympathiser or a resemblant of a movement that is known to largely hate, mock, discriminate against, and/or want to take lives of a group of people, and you were provably vocal about your hate, then you will be banned on sight.
Rule 8- All comments should try to stay relevant to their parent content.
Rule 9- Reposts from other platforms are not allowed.
Let everyone have their own content.
:::spoiler Rule 10- Majority of bots aren't allowed to participate here.
This seems quite clever by Reddit. It looks like there's some deal that if they remove ads from their apps they get free api usage for a few months. Seems suspicous that both apps doing this have removed ads.
This will soften the blow a little for Reddit as now at least 1 decent sized 3rd party app on each platform (Android/IOS) will continue to work for a while.
A clever PR move that changes nothing.
API fee is not free, only delayed. I have no idea how the devs will handle the combined bill when it comes. It'll be a huge bill while income from subscriptions have not really picked up yet. I would not take this risk even if someone give me Appollo source code for free.
I don't think they will be paying anything until they implement subscriptions. They are exempt for now in exchange for removing advertising from their apps.
Once they implement subscriptions then they get income to cover the cost of the api.
You're right that this is a PR move rather than a genuine attempt to work with devs, but I think it would have been more clever if Reddit had done this three weeks ago, when they could have undermined the "this will kill third party apps" narrative. Instead, they waited until Huffman had spouted off about how he admires Elon, who killed Twitter's third party apps, and how the API was "never meant" for third party apps. Basically, he has expressed a personal desire to see third party apps killed, and usually the CEO's opinion overrules official company statements with this kind of thing. So now, it's going to be hard for the company to turn around and claim that killing third party apps isn't their end goal.
The new API requires you to remove ads regardless, they could get banned by reddit for serving their own ads.
Yep you are correct. The new terms require you to earn no income to use the api for free. It's probably not some sort of deal then.
Wonder why the devs waited until the last minute to announce it. Makes sense for devs to try and ring some final value from their app.
I will continue to work - partially. No nsfw, and usage limits. So all the subs that have gone nsfw in protest are just not gonna show up, unless the app is scraping the rss feed or something.
Reddit has been forcible cracking protest-NSFW subs, though. They're messaging mod teams and threatening removal and replacement for "turning a sub NSFW" or for encouraging users to submit NSFW content, if the sub wasn't NSFW to begin with.
@fruitcake119 I thought Reddit intentionally doesn’t funnel ads to or allow 3rd party apps to have ads?
I believe Reddit did not provide their ads through the API (aka the ones integrated into the feeds), but some apps still had generic app ads (like the little banner ones provided by Google AdSense glued at the bottom of the app).
It doesn't, but several apps were previously funded by sourcing their own ads. That's why the double-whammy of Reddit hiking API charges to 20X their own costs and prohibiting third-party apps from showing their own ads was such a problem - by prohibiting ads, Reddit was saying that apps effectively had to be funded by charging users, they couldn't just go find outside sources of funding.
Marketers care an unreasonable amount about how their ads show up from a UI/X perspective. It's meaningless, but these people stake their roles on it, convincing entire industries it matters. Then you get some marketers who are laid off entering consultation and keeping the wheels turning on these ideas....
Ask me how I know 😮💨
Anyways, imagine Reddit looking to go IPO and asking their customers (marketers buying ads) what they can do to improve their services to these patrons, and you get /u/spez breaking his back to please them ahead of the customers their patrons would reach.
Some people have trouble letting go I guess. First of all, after all that has happened why any developer would choose to continue doing business with Reddit is beyond me. Reddit has demonstrated they will shaft you on a moment's notice (ok a month's notice), go back on their word, lie about developers for PR points, etc. Reddit is not a good business partner.
Second, who is this even for? What percentage of Relay users are going to pay for a limited version of Reddit with usage limits? The only reason Reddit is making these deals with Relay and Narwhal is because Reddit thinks they won't succeed in staying alive. Reddit thinks the vast majority of Relay/Narwhal users will decide its too expensive to use these apps to get a worse experience, so will end up on the official app. Reddit gets some to hold these up as examples of reasonable developers who were willing to work with Reddit, unlike those crying babies that are closing their apps. And if Reddit is wrong, and Relay/Narwhal stay profitable and active, then we're just back to point 1 - Reddit will just turn the screws on the AI pricing until they get crushed.
This just feels like an abusive relationship. Dave just needs to accept reality - Reddit TPA's are dead (and Reddit as a whole isn't long for this world either). I've used Relay for years, very disappointed in the developer. I'm still deleting July 1.
Exactly this. Relay was a great app and I will miss it and Reddit. I would love for Dbrady to start fresh with Relay for Lemmy but I imagine that is quite a bit of work and maybe he just doesn't feel up to it. I wish him the best no matter what happens!
I uninstalled Relay and moved on. Kinda wished DBrady would have done the same. I don't want Reddit get paid for their shitty behaviour.
I just feel bad for the devs of TPA. They created so much value for reddit when reddit didn't even HAVE an app. Then reddit shafts them so hard for all the work they put in. Fuck reddit.
Reddit gets to hold these up as examples of reasonable developers who were willing to work with Reddit, unlike those crying babies that are closing their apps.
This deserves to be repeated. Like… I get why one would want to not let their project die, but we all know this is exactly what’s going to happen. These few who remain will funnel a ton of money into Reddit’s pocket for a worse experience all so that they can be used to further slander the devs of the 3PAs who were forced out from the API changes. In a couple months when the last few 3PAs inevitably go under, I don’t know if a single tear will be shed because the writing on the wall is so obvious.
Nearly agree with everything you said.
But maybe Reddit is okay with a few 3rd party apps surviving if it means they can charge such a ridiculous premium on API requests. Perhaps they didn't think any dev would be crazy enough to take them up on their offer. But at that point, they're raking in so much money that they might not care those users are on a 3rd party app.
That's a fair point. If Relay and co hang on to a few thousand users and pay a cost per month 5x what it's worth to reddit to have those users on its app, your right reddit might be like fuck it this works for us. At the end of the day, whatever is most profitable to reddit. For the most part, that means using the official reddit app so reddit can track you. But if some dumb devs are willing to pay more than Reddit would get from direct data harvesting, let them go. No, I think your right.
I think a few apps is key though, they want the majority of their users locked in.
I also use Relay, and I'm not sure how I feel about this move. I'm using reddit less and less since the blackout, and mostly just to check on the protest at this point. I love the Relay app, and DBrady is an incredible dev, but I refuse to give money to reddit after this whole debacle, especially for an app that will be stripped of it's full capability,
Thanks for this well-written roundup of what's going on. I think you've hit the nail on the head. I just hope the dev doesn't rack up debt in the time the app is free...
It does seem like Reddit is giving these apps some rope to hang on to.... Whether they'll hang in the bad way remains to be seen.
The instant removal of ads is definitely coming from Reddit. Reddit is already putting on the screws, in a way, preventing these devs from making any ad-revenue in the interrim.
Until the subscription option actually becomes available, the devs will have NO source of income.
It's displaying reddit content still? For money? Lmfao
I can't believe that with the API pricing the way it is, it's financially viable to continue developing this app. It only makes sense if Spez offered this (and some other developers) a backroom deal (complete with NDA).
Spez has shown himself to be a lying, vindictive douche. If he can make Christian Selig look bad (for exposing reddit and Spez himself for what he is), it's something he would appear to relish. The way Spez doubled-down on his vindictive and defamatory statements during the AMA just goes to show that there's no level he won't sink to.
Also, if the API pricing was lowered - it's a last minute sign of (quietly) back-tracking given the immense backlash it has caused.
The initial API pricing was meant to drive out all reddit clients. It seems to me that reddit clients still operating after July the 1st have received (much) lower API pricing (or are not being charged at all - in the case of RedReader). It's just too expensive otherwise.
It's disheartening that they are the ones that got screwed and yet they keep supporting the company...
It make sense in the short term. Even if this only works for 6 or 12 months, they might make more to live on in that time, than they would converting the app to Lemmy right now, simply due to the massive difference in user-count.
It might be the "right" call to stick with Reddit, getting the scraps that are still there, while Lemmy is still only just taking off. They can always jump ship later, though others will have a head start by then.
Ethically? Different matter.
This is the answer. From the devs point of view it's getting the most value out of the product they have spent years making.
For Reddit it's a good PR move.
They, and the Infinity dev, will just get fucked by Reddit in some way. Again.
And narwhal. I can't see this working in the long run. They are only granting access to a subset of content, in exchange for a price that people don't have to pay if they use the "real" app. This is doomed to slowly bleed users and die.
Interested to see how this works out for them and how strongly he'll be able to optimize his app, I'd be keen on getting a breakdown of user statistics (to see how many calls are getting done every hour for example)
Maybe with some of these apps still sticking around, the migration to the fediverse will benefit because less people will be flooding these new spaces all at once
I've been a Relay user for a long time, but the time has passed. I would have been happy enough to pay a small monthly fee for the app, but Reddit's days as being the only real option are over.
To each their own but when Apollo died, Reddit died for me. It would feel disrespectful to continue to use Reddit at this point, both to the devs forced off and to myself.
I don’t see how this would be successful. It’s a gutted version of the API as it is. Sanitized. No NSFW subs. Reddit as it was is dead and even if Apollo and BaconReader came back I would still not go back.
Even with a subscription cost for the API, users still won't be getting any NSFW posts. That includes porn obviously but there was also tons of non-porn NSFW content in subs like /r/drugs, /r/sex, etc.
Piggybacking on the point: People keep repeating Reddit’s line that non-porn NSFW will be allowed, but every time anybody (including Selig) asked how Reddit will manage to differentiate types of NSFW, it’s been radio silence on Reddit’s end.
Despite Reddit’s promises I do think it will end up being a blanket NSFW ban.
I think it will cause all sorts of problems if Reddit tries to actually slice the line. What’s the difference between art and porn? Would a hypothetical subreddit like “artistic photos of naked women” be porn? If not, what about photos of topless protests? Could a subreddit made entirely of photos of topless protestors be considered NSFW but not porn? What about something like a subreddit of clothed women sticking their bare feet at the camera- would that be able to simply not mark itself NSFW since it isn’t actually showing anything explicitly sexual?
When there’s no official line it’s so much easier to mark things NSFW out of an abundance of caution. When marking things NSFW or determining porn from non-porn NSFW actually affects user experience it’s going to become a headache for all involved.
This subscription costs will end up in Reddits pocket. Why would you want to do that?
Anyone considering : cut bait and move on.
Oof