this post was submitted on 21 Jun 2023
19 points (100.0% liked)
13633 readers
1 users here now
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I think the more pessimistic view is that rather than removing downvoting entirely, they'll just lie on the votes for select threads. This isn't technologically difficult, nor does it need to be done manually. They could do something broad like making any admin flair post simply not count downvotes, guaranteeing it'll have a "net positive" (or maybe averaging karma from nearby positive comments, to avoid it being suspicious when an admin replies to a +10k comment and only gets +500).
I see that as more devious because it'll be hard to detect it's happening and the fact that you can still downvote other comments would lead to disbelief that it's what's happening.
Reddit already fudges numbers although not to that extent. If you go to someone's page from their profile and downvote all their comments it won't actually count.
Exact upvotes and downvotes are also a little fluid, it'll give you a number within a range but not an exact amount depending on the amount of interaction on a post.
This is not exactly true.
It's not that the votes don't count, it's that Reddit uses a particular technique where the karma you see is randomly modified every time to make it impossible to see if your vote has an effect.
The goal is to prevent bots from realizing when they have been shadow banned. It makes it easier to control automated vote manipulation since bots will just make a new account if they realize they're banned.
This possibly has already happened in 2016/2017. Popular r/The_Donald posts had their vote count set to zero (even while still being on the front page: https://archive.is/rfc22), and the highly-anticipated Donald Trump AMA was pushed to page 190 of r/all despite having tens of thousands of upvotes. Admins were saying that the voting algorithm was working as expected, and the posts were simply being downvoted by haters like r/EnoughTrumpSpam brigades after reaching r/all. Conveniently, since display of downvote counts was removed in 2014, this was impossible to verify. Admins clearly hated r/The_Donald and have made multiple changes to the front page algorithm just to make their posts show up less. It's possible they were modifying the vote counts in the database directly, but there was no clear proof at the time.
Coincidentally, 2017 was the same year when u/spez/ did get caught modifying the database to edit users' comments, and he only admitted to it because there was clear proof of that. The users he "pranked" were incidentally r/The_Donald posters.
More recently, Spez removed most of the downvotes on his recent AMA thread, and someone took a screenshot before it did it. If I remember correctly (not visiting Reddit to check), it went from being comparable to the infamous "sense of pride and accomplishment" comment to only having like 5 downvotes, and hundreds of people in the comments were calling him out on it.